Sounds un-American, doesn’t it.
One of our church leaders is retired military. He and his family lived many years in England, and there was only one “C of C” congregation for many miles around. I’ve heard him comment several times about the diversity that existed in the congregation – diversity in theology, convictions, opinions, practices, etc. As he’s said, “We had to get along; we had no choice.”
I’ve often been asked, “Is denominationalism (the existence of so many churches in most communities) wrong?” Of course it is! Wait! Don’t “X” me! I’m not saying “my” church is the only true church and all others are wrong. I’m including the church I belong to (Churches of Christ) in the above statement. The divisiveness that is Christianity in America is one of the main reasons why so many in our society reject the Christian faith.
Why do you think all these churches exist? Because people either could not get along or they disagreed theologically to the extent that they could not worship their Creator in the same building. How could that not be wrong? There are individual congregations that are organized for convenience sake (travel time, etc.), but that is the exception rather than the rule as to the existence of multiple churches in most towns. (A community of 15,000 I lived in for 20 years had 4 “CofC”s, not counting small house churches, plus dozens of other “brands”.)
“But the New Testament doesn’t condemn denominationalism.” Of course it doesn’t; it didn’t exist in the first century, when the church came into existence, and probably could not be conceived of in the minds of the New Testament writers. As the church spread throughout the Roman Empire and other regions, there were Jewish, pagan, and Christian “congregations” in most towns. For Christians, you were either in the “church” or you weren’t. If you had disagreements, you either worked them out or you left the church. There were no other churches to move to that would suit you better.
Why do you think so much space in the New Testament letters is dedicated to in-Christ relationships – treating each other “like Christ” and working out problems and disagreements? The people these letters were written to had no choice! And it was not that they hadn’t had enough time to create other churches that would ”suit their taste”; there was only one church – the church Jesus died to create. In larger communitiies there might be multiple sites where Christians would meet – house churches – but there were not different churches. You didn’t leave the house church on the south side of town to attend the house church on the north side of town because you didn’t like the fact that the south side house church clapped when they sang! Come on, people! Read your Bibles!
Because a situation exists today that did not exist when the New Testament was written, I suppose it would be difficult to condemn the existence of multiple churches and people jumping from one to another. But what can be addressed with certainty are the attitudes that have created such a confusing picture of the Christian faith, especially in our society. If we would be more humble, understanding of others, committed to the truth that is Scripture rather than treating it as a book of suggestions, more focused on others becoming Christians than being able to “do church the right (i.e. my) way”, committed to helping fellow travelers successfully finish the journey that is life, I think much of this mess we see in the Christian community would go away.
Ecumenism (unifying the Christian community) has failed. We can call each other “brother”/”sister”, but what divides us remains. One or two combined efforts a year – Community Thanksgiving Service, Community Singing, etc. – is not unity. We are still divided, our people still jump from one church to another (and we gladly welcome them as evidence that “our way” is better), and we feel no need to put forth every effort possible to work out our differences for the sake of Jesus’ cause. And Jesus’ prayer goes unheeded in our world today.
Father, may they all be one as you are in me and I am in you; may they be in us, for by this unity the world will believe that you sent me. (John 17:21 “The Voice”)
“Lord God, give me the courage and the heart to preach and practice unity among believers, beginning with those I minister to each day. Amen.”
Now to the God who can do so many awe-inspiring things, immeasurable things, things greater than we ever could ask or imagine through the power at work in us, to him be all glory in the church and in Jesus Christ, from this generation to the next, forever and ever. Amen. (Ephesians 3:20-21 “The Voice”)
Blessings.
Glenn